It shows how much power big business can wield when they spread doubt about the scientific research that isnt in their favor read full summary on blinkist. This merchants of doubt summary tells the story of a small but. Merchants of doubt by naomi oreskes and erik m conway book. John has more than 30 years in energy and the environment with government, private. The story begins in the 1950s with the tobacco industrys strategy. A merchant of doubt attacks merchants of doubt posted on 20 december 2010 by john cook. Merchants of doubt summary and study guide supersummary. Oreskes was the speaker at the citizens climate lobby june teleconference call and the red lake ccl group was. It is the definitive report on global warming, and its frightening. Jun 03, 2010 merchants of doubt tells the story of how a looseknit group of highlevel scientists and scientific advisers, with deep connections in politics and industry, ran effective campaigns to mislead the public and deny wellestablished scientific knowledge over four decades. Doubt is crucial to sciencein the version we call curiosity or healthy skepticism, it drives science forwardbut it also makes science vulnerable to misrepresentation, because it is easy to take uncertainties out of context and create the impression that everything is unresolved. The bold design pleasd highly those infernal states, and joy sparkld in all thir eyes.
Merchants of doubt by naomi oreskes and erik m conway. Featured content includes commentary on major characters, 25. Conway includes detailed chapter summaries and analysis covering 7 chapters, as well as several more indepth sections of expertwritten literary analysis. This 81page guide for merchants of doubt by naomi oreskes and eric m.
Merchants of doubt how a handful of scientists obscured. It was made into a film, merchants of doubt, directed by robert kenner, released in 2014. I was impressed by the book and, in some areas, this went beyond the book. The second hand smoke issue alright lets talk about tobacco again. While the idea of equal time for opposing opinions makes sense in a twoparty political system, it does not work for science, because science is not about opinion. Merchants of doubt how a handful of scientists obscure the truth about climate change. The merchants prologue and tale book summaries, test. Merchants of doubt tells the story of how a looseknit group of highlevel scientists and scientific advisers, with deep connections in politics and industry, ran effective campaigns to mislead the public and deny wellestablished scientific knowledge over four decades. A resource book a howto handbook for fact fighters, providing example after example of successful strategies for undermining science, and a list of experts with scientific credentials available to comment on. If youre looking for free book summaries, this is the single best page on the internet. Mar 06, 2015 nprs melissa block speaks to director robert kenner about his documentary, merchants of doubt, which examines the work of climate change skeptics and their campaign to sway public opinion. Merchants of doubt by naomi oreskes overdrive rakuten. Merchants of doubt how a handful of scientists obscured the. In seven compelling chapters addressing tobacco, acid.
Merchants of doubt is a 2014 american documentary film directed by robert kenner and inspired by the 2010 book of the same name by naomi oreskes and erik m. Mckie says that merchants of doubt includes detailed notes on all sources used, is carefully paced, and is my runaway contender for best science book of the year. It identifies parallels between the global warming controversy and earlier controversies over tobacco smoking, acid rain, ddt, and the. If you are the publisher or author of this book and feel that. The husband, who has been a worthy knight for 60 years and a libertine for most of his life, finally decides to set aside his liberty and marry, believing that marriage. The merchant, with his cynical and bitter view of marriage, indirectly supports and expands the clerks point with a story of a foolish old husband and a deceitful young wife. Merchants of doubt is a nonfiction account of how a looseknit group of scientists fred seitz, fred singer, bill nierenberg, and robert jastrowwith similar. Merchants of doubt explores work of climate change deniers. It is a melancholy object to those, who walk through this great town, or travel in the country, when they see the streets, the roads and cabbindoors crowded with beggars of the female sex, followed by three, four, or six children, all in rags, and importuning every passenger for an alms.
While not flawless, merchants of doubt is an immensely important and timely book. Access a free summary of merchants of doubt, by naomi oreskes and erik m. These people are particularly proud of how successful they are in their craft. The film traces the use of public relations tactics that were originally developed by the tobacco industry to protect their business from research indicating health risks from smoking. It is, and we ignore this message at our peril elizabeth kolbert if you read just one book on climate change this year, read merchants of doubt. When you put the stories side by sidelike the book doesyou start noticing that their strategies are always the same. In their new book, merchants of doubt, historians naomi oreskes and erik conway explain how a looseknit group of highlevel scientists, with extensive political connections, ran effective campaigns to mislead the public and deny wellestablished scientific knowledge over four decades. This story started rather quietly in 1963 when a group of scientist realized that acidic rain was falling in hubbard brooka closely monitored forest area used to understand many aspects of its ecosystem 1. A documentary that looks at punditsforhire who present themselves as scientific authorities as they speak about topics like toxic chemicals, pharmaceuticals and climate change. Fred singer was closely affiliated with the heritage foundation 4, and he was a master at exploiting doubt. At the beginning of this post i mentioned that there was a readers digests article in 1953 titled cancer by the carton which caused cold sweat to run down the spine of tobacco ceos. He practised on her affection in that systematic way, that he got great sums of money from her, and he induced her to buy her brother out of a share in the brewery which had been weakly left him by his father at an immense price, on the plea that when he was her husband he must hold and.
Hubbard brook was called an experimental forest as oxymoronic as that sounds, and the detection of acid rain in this particular place was rather a strange finding since it was. Remarkably, the same individuals surface repeatedlysome of the same. Aug 07, 2010 merchants of doubt which includes detailed notes on all sources is clearly and cleanly outlined, carefully paced and is my runaway contender for best science book of the year. Therefore the lottery that he hath devised in these three chests of gold, silver, and lead, whereof who chooses his meaning chooses you, will no doubt never be chosen by any rightly but one who shall rightly love. Remarkably, the same individuals surface repeatedly some of the same. Supersummary, a modern alternative to sparknotes and cliffsnotes, offers highquality study guides for challenging works of literature. The subject of robert kenners documentary merchants of doubt is the. But what makes the story so fascinating or rather infuriating are the methods used by the merchants of doubt. Apr 01, 2015 but theres one thing these merchants of doubt dont want you to know. Merchants of doubt shows that some of the very same individuals were part of the plans to frame the climate change debate as unproven, using the same tried and true tactics of misrepresentation of facts, nonrepresentative scientists, and industryfriendly legislators. A belief in invisible cats cannot be logically disproved, although it does tell us a good deal about those who hold it. I call upon the peace prize laureate for 2007, al gore, to come forward. The book provides a number of fascinating cases that has a direct impact on the public.
Merchants of doubt should finally put to rest the question of whether the science of climate change is settled. Oreskes and conway write that in each case keeping the controversy alive by spreading doubt and confusion after a scientific consensus had been reached, was the. Elizabeth kolbert merchants of doubt has been praisedand attackedaround the world, for reasons easy to understand. Merchants of doubt explores work of climate change. Merchants of doubt which includes detailed notes on all sources is clearly and cleanly outlined, carefully paced and is my runaway contender for best science book of the year. Not only that, the characters of the different parts of the story are always the same too. It identifies parallels between the global warming controversy and earlier controversies over tobacco smoking, acid rain, ddt, and the hole in the ozone layer. Elizabeth kolbert if you read just one book on climate change this year, read merchants of doubt. Among the multitude of documents we found in writing this book were bad science. Well have ye judgd, well ended long debate, synod of gods, and like to what ye are, great things resolvd. According to the tradition, gyges was a shepherd in the service of the king of lydia. Merchants of doubt is a 2014 american documentary film directed by robert kenner and inspired by the 2010 book of the same name by naomi oreskes and. As we see that every city is a society, and every society ed.
Use our free book summaries to learn the 3 central ideas from over 600 books in 4 minutes or less. How a handful of scientists obscured the truth on issues from tobacco smoke to global warming is a 2010 nonfiction book by american historians of science naomi oreskes and erik m. Merchants of doubt about global warming hope to strike. Merchants of doubt free summary by naomi oreskes and erik. Conway and 20000 other business, leadership and nonfiction books on.
Amazed at the sight, he descended into the opening, where, among other marvels, he beheld a hollow brazen horse. Doubt is our product after seitz retired from his illustrious scientific career, he was hired by the tobacco company rj reynolds to run its program funding biomedical research at major universities, hospitals, and research institutes across the country 10. The subject of robert kenners documentary merchants of doubt is the catastrophe of global climate change, which is engulfing us even faster than predicted. Conway and 20,000 other business, leadership and nonfiction books on getabstract. Nierenberg had changed the executive summary, and it was the science advisor to the president who had asked him to do so. Im nik, a writer from germany, and in 2016, i wrote over 365 book summaries. Conways book of the same title, examines the history of corporatefinanced public relations efforts to sow confusion and skepticism. This summary of the ideas fromnaoli oreskes and erik conways book merchants of doubt tells how a group oftop scientists ran campaigns in order to confuse the public over the validityof scientific discoveries on issues such as global warming, the dangers ofsmoking and acid rain. Merchants of doubt quotes showing of 1 while the idea of equal time for opposing opinions makes sense in a twoparty political system, it does not work for science, because science is not about opinion.
His specialty was to find something that was not 100% certain which in reality is not too hard to do, and highlight every sliver of doubt to the point that any efforts to initiate a solution would seem like a waste of money and resources. And if you have time to read two, reread merchants of doubt. Mckie says that merchants of doubt includes detailed notes on all sources used, is carefully paced, and is my runaway contender for best science book of the. Well, thirty years later, in 1983 a similar situation happened when a surgeon general report concluded that. With frederick singer, naomi oreskes, jamy ian swiss, sam roe.
Its a surprising story of a true conspiracy by the government that not many know about. Senate and that oklahoma senator jim inhofe, author of the 2012 book the greatest. In bill nierenbergs files, there is a second copy of the telecopied executive summary from may 21, but this time dated, by hand, 71084and the note next to the date reads. Inspired by the acclaimed book by naomi oreskes and erik conway, merchants of doubt takes audiences on a satirically comedic, yet illuminating ride into the heart of conjuring american spin. Conway merchants of doubt is a fascinating book that tells the upsetting story of how a small powergroup of conservative scientists ran destructive campaigns to mislead the public about science. But if there was one debate that is worth paying attention to, and actually thinking about both sides, is the one that started back in the late 1970s and early 1980s between thomas schelling. Therere not striving to be the best in the industry.
Mediocre audio, hifi recommended cd quality 56 mb or lofi 14 mb. Merchants of doubt is a nonfiction account of how a looseknit group of scientistsfred seitz, fred singer, bill nierenberg, and robert jastrowwith similar. It was amazing to see the people who use devious tricks to spread doubt and misinformation. Merchants of doubt it identifies parallels between the global warming controversy and earlier controversies over tobacco smoking, acid rain, ddt, and the hole in the ozone layer.
I would recommend both reading the book and seeing the video. Merchants of doubt free summary by naomi oreskes and erik m. How a handful of scientists obscured the truth on issues from tobacco smoke to global warming by naomi oreskes and eric m. Merchants of doubt which includes detailed notes on all sources is. Being the best means there is absolutely no room for mediocre. A parable by john patrick shanley includes detailed chapter summaries and analysis, as well as several more indepth sections of expertwritten literary analysis. Kenner doesnt waste time proving, in this terse, brilliantly argued movie, that climate change is happening or that our dependence on fossil fuels has a causal relationship to it. Study guide for colleges and universities a joint collaboration with the documentary film merchants of doubt, produced by participant media and directed by robert kenner, examines the role of pundits, scientists, government, and media in shaping public policies and perceptions regarding climate change and other issues. Now, ive complained throughout this post about the fake debates that the merchants of doubt initiate, and most of them are precisely that. Again, tried and true public reframing of reality worked. When the truth is accepted, americans will demand action before i worked for environmental defense fund, i spent three years reporting on the professional deniers for my book the climate war, a history of the great american struggle to get serious about climate change. Many people and companies settle for good because its easier.
692 491 337 603 925 1380 164 1364 164 1300 1321 1084 216 681 1058 25 1302 310 1177 685 1401 1045 1431 286 405 695 1370 988 574 1352 1460 1065 980 1086 218 806 59 1205 895 59 535 1040 708 1 797 1359